Lawsuit over pool ban is planned

Lawyers say they’re suing city of Port Townsend, YMCA

PORT TOWNSEND — Lawyers for a Port Townsend woman banned from a pool say they’re moving forward with a lawsuit over a 2022 incident involving a confrontation with a transgender woman in the locker room.

Julie Jaman, 82, was banned from the Mountain View Pool in Port Townsend in July 2022 after she confronted a transgender employee about their presence in the women’s locker room. The incident gained international news and saw several contentious protests in downtown Port Townsend.

In March, the Virginia-based Center for American Liberty (CAL) sent a letter on Jaman’s behalf to the City of Port Townsend and the Olympic Peninsula YMCA which administers the pool seeking $350,000 in damages, an apology and reinstatement of pool privileges.

The letter had initially asked for a response by March 27, but that date was extended twice until May 13 to allow for YMCA representatives to review the case, according to Eric Sell, attorney for CAL.

“We heard from the YMCA’s attorney last night,” Sell said Tuesday in an email. “He indicated to us that the YMCA is not willing to settle at this point. We never heard from the City. We are preparing a lawsuit and will file soon.”

Both the city and the YMCA declined to comment.

CAL is alleging Jaman’s First and 14th Amendment rights were violated in the ban from the pool, and Sell previously said the lawsuit would likely be filed in federal court.

Jaman was permanently banned from the YMCA’s facilities on July 26, 2022, after she confronted a transgender YMCA employee about being in the women’s locker room. The employee, Clementine Adams, was escorting children in the summer camp to the restroom.

Adams was not wearing employee identification at the time.

Jaman was notified of her ban shortly after the incident.

The banning led to several demonstrations over transgender issues, including one protest in downtown Port Townsend that drew hundreds of people and saw small scuffles between protest groups. That incident similarly drew international attention and led to another demonstration in support of Jaman by a small group for far-right protesters.

Since the letter was sent in March, Jaman and CAL attorneys have been making appearances on national and international media to discuss the case, according to CAL’s website.

CAL is a nonprofit legal center founded in 2018 by Harmeet Dhillon, a California-based attorney and committeewoman with the Republican National Committee.


Reporter Peter Segall can be reached by email at

More in News

Work begins on sewer project

Intermittent closures planned in Port Hadlock

Clallam commissioners interested in section of forest for ODT

Clallam County commissioners plan to send a letter to… Continue reading

Deputy Mayor Navarra Carr accepts a Live United Award on behalf of the city of Port Angeles.
Port Angeles honored with Live United award

The city of Port Angeles was honored with a Live… Continue reading

Smoke vents from the rear car deck doors as firefighters battle a vehicle fire aboard the ferry MV Coho upon its afternoon arrival in Port Angeles on Thursday. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula News)
Crews evaluated after RV fire on Coho ferry

Combined training helped during incident, deputy chief says

Staff favors denial for rezone

Proposal would pave way for Dollar General Plus

Clallam Transit considering proposal for Narcan at Gateway center

Board members want time for more discussion before next meeting

Turns restricted during roundabout construction

Drivers at the intersection of state highways 104 and 19… Continue reading

Bridge closures canceled for May 17, May 18

Hood Canal bridge closures originally scheduled for this weekend have… Continue reading

Roxanne Pfiefer-Fisher, a volunteer with a team from Walmart, sorts through sections of what will become a slide during Wednesday’s opening day of a community rebuild of the Dream Playground at Erickson Playfield in Port Angeles. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula News)
Volunteers flock to Dream Playground to start build

Group effort reminds organizers of efforts in 2021, 2002

Lawsuit over pool ban is planned

Lawyers say they’re suing city of Port Townsend, YMCA

Peninsula Behavioral Health adds 3 programs

Services help those experiencing psychosis, provide housing